Connect with us

Segui LiberoReporter su Google

Aggiungici alle tue Fonti Preferite per ricevere i nostri articoli in evidenza nelle tue ricerche quotidiane!

International-News

Have sanctions against Russia worked? An analysis between myth and reality

Have sanctions against Russia worked? An analysis between myth and reality

Two years after the start of the conflict in Ukraine, the impact of Western sanctions is controversial: has Moscow really been weakened or has it managed to circumvent them?

Since February 2022, the European Union, the G7 and the United States have adopted over 13,000 restrictive measures against Russia in an attempt to hit its economy, isolate it financially and undermine its ability to sustain the war effort in Ukraine. However, more than two years later, the debate remains heated: have the sanctions really worked?

The effect on energy revenues
The primary objective of the sanctions was to reduce Russia’s revenues from energy exports. Oil and gas revenues accounted for over 40% of Russia’s federal budget in 2021. With the European embargo on oil by sea and the introduction of price caps, the aim was to limit Russia’s profit margin. However, Moscow was able to redirect exports to countries such as China and India, selling crude oil at a discount but maintaining high volumes. The result? Energy revenues declined in 2023 but rose again in 2024 thanks to higher international prices and the circumvention of the imposed caps.

Ruble, inflation and industrial capacity
In the first year of sanctions, the rouble showed signs of resilience, thanks in part to internal capital controls and the requirement for exporting companies to convert a portion of their revenues into the national currency. However, since 2023, the picture has changed: the currency has weakened steadily, inflation has risen above 7% and the Central Bank has had to raise rates to 16%. Increasing military spending has supported industrial production, but at the cost of a growing imbalance in public finances.

Evasion and triangulation: the issue of “buffer countries”
One of the biggest problems with the sanctions regime is its evasion. Technological goods subject to embargoes often entered Russia through third countries: Armenia, Turkey, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Georgia saw a boom in exports to Moscow, often in sectors such as electronic components and precision mechanics. The EU has tried to counter this phenomenon with new rules against re-exportation, but the results are still partial.

The paradox of European exports
Another significant fact is that, despite the sanctions, in 2024 some European companies continued — directly or indirectly — to do business with Russia. This was particularly the case in “non-strategic” sectors or through local joint ventures that were not formally sanctioned. Trade has changed, but it has not collapsed.

The social and political stability of the regime
One of the most anticipated effects of the sanctions was a possible internal destabilisation of the regime. But so far, the Kremlin has maintained political control. The repressive apparatus, patriotic rhetoric and control over the media have prevented mass protests. On the contrary, the system has adapted, leveraging economic nationalism and new global alliances.

Effective, but not decisive
The sanctions have affected the Russian economy, slowing it down and forcing it to redefine its priorities. They have limited access to advanced technologies, compressed energy profit margins and weakened the rouble. However, they have not caused a collapse, nor have they stopped the war machine. Russia has shown greater economic resilience than expected, thanks in part to a global network of circumvention and the availability of new trading partners. Sanctions, therefore, work, but they are not enough on their own.

THE LATEST NEWS

Trump Jokes About His Makeup Use While Mocking Georgia Democrat Ossoff

At a campaign rally in Dalton, Georgia, the president offered a rare personal admission about cosmetics before turning the moment...
Read More
Trump Jokes About His Makeup Use While Mocking Georgia Democrat Ossoff

UK Storm Shadow Support for Ukraine Aims to Boost Pressure on U.S. Aid

A British defense analyst says London’s latest military assistance package is unlikely to alter the battlefield in the short term...
Read More
UK Storm Shadow Support for Ukraine Aims to Boost Pressure on U.S. Aid

White House Spokeswoman Katie Zacharia May Exit Role Days After Appointment

Just five days into her tenure, Katie Zacharia is facing mounting pressure after allegations she falsely claimed to be a...
Read More
White House Spokeswoman Katie Zacharia May Exit Role Days After Appointment

Pope Leo XIV Urges Oleshky Humanitarian Truce in Call With Putin

Speaking from Rome’s Gemelli Hospital while recovering from lung cancer surgery, the pontiff pressed for humanitarian access to the embattled...
Read More
Pope Leo XIV Urges Oleshky Humanitarian Truce in Call With Putin

Russian Defector Who Aided Ukrainian Strikes Joins Anti-Putin Unit

After helping Ukrainian forces target Russian positions responsible for more than 300 casualties, former communications officer Lev Stupnikov crossed the...
Read More
Russian Defector Who Aided Ukrainian Strikes Joins Anti-Putin Unit

Princess Diana’s Secret Nighttime Missions in London Revealed by Former Royal Aide

Former royal press secretary Dickie Arbiter says Princess Diana regularly slipped away from Kensington Palace at night to check on...
Read More
Princess Diana’s Secret Nighttime Missions in London Revealed by Former Royal Aide

(Source: AndKronos)

LATEST NEWS

Gas russo, la proposta di Trump all’Europa: Putin incassa, Kiev teme il peggio
Gas russo, la proposta di Trump all’Europa: Putin incassa, Kiev teme il peggio
Canada, incendio nella base militare di Wainwright: morti e feriti
Canada, incendio nella base militare di Wainwright: morti e feriti
Papa Leone XIV dimesso dal Gemelli dopo cinque giorni di ricovero
Papa Leone XIV dimesso dal Gemelli dopo cinque giorni di ricovero
Trump aiuta ancora Putin: sospese le nuove sanzioni contro Mosca
Trump aiuta ancora Putin: sospese le nuove sanzioni contro Mosca
Droga da Roma al Centro Italia: 8 misure cautelari, sequestrati 187 mila euro
Droga da Roma al Centro Italia: 8 misure cautelari, sequestrati 187 mila euro
Chemsex e infezioni sessualmente trasmesse, l’allarme dei SerD: prevenzione ancora carente
Chemsex e infezioni sessualmente trasmesse, l’allarme dei SerD: prevenzione ancora carente
Trump Jokes About His Makeup Use While Mocking Georgia Democrat Ossoff
Trump Jokes About His Makeup Use While Mocking Georgia Democrat Ossoff
Putin parla con Papa Leone XIV, ma non apre sulla guerra: «Avanti con gli attacchi»
Putin parla con Papa Leone XIV, ma non apre sulla guerra: «Avanti con gli attacchi»
UK Storm Shadow Support for Ukraine Aims to Boost Pressure on U.S. Aid
UK Storm Shadow Support for Ukraine Aims to Boost Pressure on U.S. Aid
Yemen, missili degli Houthi contro l’aeroporto di Aden: tre lanci segnalati
Yemen, missili degli Houthi contro l’aeroporto di Aden: tre lanci segnalati
WhatsApp down in Italia, problemi nell’invio dei messaggi: disservizio rientrato
WhatsApp down in Italia, problemi nell’invio dei messaggi: disservizio rientrato
White House Spokeswoman Katie Zacharia May Exit Role Days After Appointment
White House Spokeswoman Katie Zacharia May Exit Role Days After Appointment
Dl Bollette, intesa tra Italia e Ue: via libera preliminare alle misure
Dl Bollette, intesa tra Italia e Ue: via libera preliminare alle misure
Pope Leo XIV Urges Oleshky Humanitarian Truce in Call With Putin
Pope Leo XIV Urges Oleshky Humanitarian Truce in Call With Putin
Vittorio Sgarbi, condizioni stabili al Gemelli: «Equilibrio delicato»
Vittorio Sgarbi, condizioni stabili al Gemelli: «Equilibrio delicato»
Zelensky avverte l’Europa: «Se cadiamo, 20 milioni di ucraini arriveranno da voi»
Zelensky avverte l’Europa: «Se cadiamo, 20 milioni di ucraini arriveranno da voi»
Papa Leone XIV, migliorano le condizioni: Angelus si farà
Papa Leone XIV, migliorano le condizioni: Angelus si farà
Russian Defector Who Aided Ukrainian Strikes Joins Anti-Putin Unit
Russian Defector Who Aided Ukrainian Strikes Joins Anti-Putin Unit
Midterm Usa, il caro-benzina pesa sulle famiglie e complica la sfida elettorale
Midterm Usa, il caro-benzina pesa sulle famiglie e complica la sfida elettorale
Licenziata per una flatulenza, autista fa causa all’azienda: il giudice respinge le accuse
Licenziata per una flatulenza, autista fa causa all’azienda: il giudice respinge le accuse