Shannon Agofsky and Len Davis oppose commutation of sentence to hostile life sentence, fearing it will damage their legal battle
Two of the 37 federal death row inmates pardoned by President Joe Biden have chosen to reject the act of clemency, which would commute their sentence to hostile life imprisonment. They are Shannon Agofsky and Len Davis, both held in the federal penitentiary in Terre Haute, Indiana. The two convicts have filed an emergency appeal to block the commutation, arguing that accepting life imprisonment would undermine their attempts to have their sentences reviewed and to assert their avowed innocence.
According to NBC, Agofsky and Davis fear that commutation would reduce the visibility of their case. In particular, they argue that since they are no longer under the threat of capital punishment, their appeals would receive less ‘attention’ from the courts, reducing the chances of reviewing the evidence in their favour.
However, legal experts are sceptical about the success of this move. Dan Kobil, a constitutionalist at Capital University Law School in Columbus, Ohio, explained that the pardon denial has little chance of prevailing. In fact, the Supreme Court ruled in a 1927 decision that the president has the power to grant pardons and commute sentences without needing the consent of the convicted.
Nevertheless, the lawyers of Agofsky and Davis are trying to continue their battle, pointing out that hostile life imprisonment, while keeping them off death row, hinders the possibility of reopening their cases, which would be more likely for prisoners still on death row.
THE LATEST NEWS
9 Agosto 2026
The boat overturned late Saturday near Liberty Island with 14 people aboard. Twelve people were rescued from the water, while...
Read More
8 Agosto 2026
In a BBC interview, Hunter Biden said former President Joe Biden's cancer has spread to his bones and described his...
Read More
7 Agosto 2026
U.S. intelligence assessments reportedly envision scenarios ranging from cyberattacks to a limited ground incursion against a NATO member, potentially between...
Read More
7 Agosto 2026
The actors are said to have held a private celebration on August 4 at a luxury estate in Surrey, months...
Read More
7 Agosto 2026
A Marion County resident has died after contracting Vibrio vulnificus, bringing Florida's reported death toll from the potentially fatal bacterial...
Read More
7 Agosto 2026
A federal appeals court has upheld a halt to construction of Donald Trump’s proposed White House ballroom, giving the administration...
Read More
6 Agosto 2026
Conflicting accounts have emerged over the state of U.S. weapons stockpiles as the Trump administration balances military pressure and diplomacy...
Read More
6 Agosto 2026
Ceuta's mayor describes last week's mass border crossing as an attack on Spain's territorial integrity, while the European Commission prepares...
Read More
(Photo: © AndKronos)